I find that arranging a piece for classical guitar puts me in touch with the music in a unique way. It gives me a chance to step right into someone else’s thought process, and I get to take part in some of the decision making they faced.
Recently, I was arranging a piano piece named Irene Waltz attributed to M.C. Bales. As I dug into the history of the piece to better understand its context, I stumbled down a rabbit hole. First, I found that the composer was quite unknown but that the little we knew about him or her was the relationship to the publishing house A.W. Perry and Sons. This in turn led me to read about the golden age of music publishing and, particularly, the fabled New York songwriting district known as Tin Pan Alley.
In the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, before radio and streaming dominated our cultural landscape, music was an industry built entirely on sheet music. That brought me to Tin Pan Alley, centered around 28th Street in Manhattan, which got its famous nickname from a journalist who described the sound of dozens of songwriters pounding away on cheap upright pianos with paper taped to the strings to sound like tin pans, all trying to pitch their tunes at the same time. It was a bustling, commercial, yet deeply vibrant ecosystem. But more than just an industry, it represented a fundamental way in which human beings interacted with art.
Delving into this era left me with a profound sense of hope and optimism. Today, we live in an era where music is overwhelmingly consumed passively. We press play on curated playlists created by algorithms while we scroll through feeds designed to drain our attention spans. I think it often leaves us with a strange sense of emptiness.
But during the golden age of publishing, music was something you made yourself in the home. Families gathered around the piano in the parlor, friends harmonized together on front porches, and everyday musicians bought sheet music of pieces like Irene Waltz because they wanted to live inside the melody, not just hear it once and swipe away. People had to make their own music, and they did. The barrier to entry wasn't technical a one; it was simply a matter of participation.
I learned that, when the recording industry eventually took over, many cultural critics panicked, fearing it was the death of genuine musical expression. But looking back, we can see it wasn't the death of music at all—it was just a different medium. Human beings have need for artistic expression, and people will seek out music no matter what. Whether it’s pounding out a tune on a parlor piano in 1910, recording a track in a bedroom today, or arranging a forgotten waltz for classical guitar, the impulse is identical. We want to connect and to create.
Arranging Irene Waltz reminded me how strong the creative impulse is in us. For me, the process is like a conversation across time and it is something worth being endlessly optimistic about.